2021—2023年十堰市生活饮用水氟化物分布及健康风险评估

Distribution characteristics and health risk assessment of fluoride in domestic drinking water in Shiyan City, 2021−2023

  • 摘要:
    背景 氟元素在生活饮用水中广泛分布,可能直接影响水质和居民的饮水安全,从而对人体健康造成一定的不良影响。
    目的 了解十堰市生活饮用水氟化物水平、分布特征,评估饮水途径中氟化物对不同人群的健康风险。
    方法 监测2021—2023年十堰市生活饮用水中氟化物的浓度,采用秩和检验的方法,对不同年份、采水期、采样类型、水源类型、消毒方式以及不同地区之间的氟化物浓度差异进行比较,基于Spearman秩相关分析探究氟化物与水体其他理化指标间的相关性。基于《中国人群暴露参数手册》中推荐的不同年龄段人群的总饮水摄入量和体重参数,采用美国国家环境保护局健康风险评估模型评估饮水途径中氟化物在不同人群中的健康风险。
    结果 采集十堰市2021—2023年生活饮用水检测水样共894份,水样全部检出氟化物。饮用水中氟化物浓度在0.015~0.920 mg·L−1之间,中位数为0.17 mg·L−1,均低于GB 5749—2022《生活饮用水卫生标准》限值(氟化物浓度≤1.0 mg·L−1)。不同年份、采水期、水样类型、采样类型、水源类型、消毒方式及地区之间的氟浓度存在统计学差异(P<0.05)。氟化物浓度随着年份呈现“先降后升”的趋势;枯水期高于丰水期;末梢水>出厂水>二次供水;不同消毒方式中,使用复合二氧化氯消毒水样氟化物浓度最低,“不消毒”水样浓度最高;农村水高于城市水;不同水源中泉水的氟化物浓度高,浅井低;不同地区间也存在统计学差异。Spearman秩相关结果表明氟化物与水中溶解性总固体、硫酸盐、浑浊度、总硬度、四氯化碳、砷、铁、硝酸盐氮、氯化物、铜、色度及pH均呈正相关(P均<0.05);而与耗氧量、氨氮、锰、铅、镉、铝、锌、氰化物、三氯甲烷、阴离子合成洗涤剂、汞和铬之间呈负相关(P均<0.05)。根据对不同人群的健康风险评估,结果显示居民通过饮水摄入氟化物的非致癌危害系数(HQ)的范围为0.005~0.993,均小于1;饮用水氟化物对6~9岁儿童的平均HQ为0.184,显著高于其他年龄段人群。
    结论 十堰市生活饮用水氟化物浓度处于低水平;采水期、水样类型、消毒方式等多种因素影响氟化物浓度,且氟化物浓度与水中氯化物、硫酸盐、pH等存在一定相关性;经饮水途径摄入氟化物的非致癌风险处于可忽略水平,但需要注意的是,非致癌风险程度受年龄、地区、消毒方式等因素的影响。

     

    Abstract:
    Background Elemental fluorine is widely distributed in domestic drinking water, which may directly affect water quality and the safety of residents' drinking water, thus causing certain adverse human health effects.
    Objective To understand the level and distribution characteristics of fluoride in domestic drinking water in Shiyan City, and to assess the health risk of fluoride in drinking water among different populations.
    Methods The concentration of fluoride in domestic drinking water in Shiyan City was monitored from 2021 to 2023. Rank sum test was used to compare the differences in fluoride concentration by years, water collection periods, sampling types, water source types, disinfection methods, and regions, and Spearman's rank correlation was used to estimate the correlation between fluoride and other water physicochemical indicators. Based on the total drinking water intake and body weight parameters recommended for different age groups in the Chinese Population Exposure Parameters Handbook, the health risk of fluoride via drinking water among different populations was assessed using the health risk assessment model of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA).
    Results A total of 894 water samples were collected from Shiyan City in 2021−2023. The fluoride concentration in the samples ranged from 0.015 to 0.920 mg·L−1, with a median of 0.17 mg·L−1, which was lower than the limit value of GB 5749-2022 Standards for Domestic Drinking Water (fluoride concentration ≤1.0 mg·L−1). There were significant differences in fluoride concentrations between different years, water collection periods, water sample types, sampling types, water source types, disinfection modes and regions (P < 0.05). Regarding fluoride variation patters, a trend of first decreasing and then increasing over the years was identified; dry season was higher than wet season; top water>finished water>secondary water supply; among the different disinfection methods, the lowest concentration of fluoride was found in the water samples treated by chlorine dioxide, and the highest was in the non-disinfected water samples; among different water sources, the highest level was found in springs, and the lowest level in shallow wells; significant differences were also found among different regions . The Spearman's rank correlation results showed positive correlations of fluoride with total dissolved solids, sulphate, turbidity, total hardness, carbon tetrachloride, arsenic, iron, nitrate-nitrogen, chloride, copper, colour, and pH (P < 0.05); and negative correlations with oxygen consumption, ammonia nitrogen, manganese, lead, cadmium, aluminium, zinc, cyanide, chloroform, anionic synthetic detergents, mercury, and chromium (P < 0.05). The results of health risk assessment showed that the non-carcinogenic hazard guotient (HQ) of fluoride intake through drinking water ranged from 0.005 to 0.993, which were less than 1. The average HQ of fluoride in drinking water for children aged 6-9 years was 0.184, which was significantly higher than that for other age groups.
    Conclusion The concentration of fluoride in drinking water in Shiyan City is at a low level; various factors such as water collection period, water sample type, and disinfection method affect the concentration of fluoride, and there is a certain correlation between fluoride and chlorides, sulphate & pH in the water; the non-carcinogenic risk of fluoride ingested by drinking water is at a negligible level, but it should be noted that the level of non-carcinogenic risk is affected by age, region, disinfection method, and other factors.

     

/

返回文章
返回